The following list is taken from boards in the church of St. Andrews. They are copies of the original registers held in Portsmouth Record Office.
| Date From | Date To | Rector | Patron |
| 1227? | 1231? | ||
| 1287 | Eudo de Stourton | ||
| 1302 | Henry de Islep | Jullianne de Stourton | |
| 1316 | Henry de Stebbenhulthe | ||
| 1324 | John de Stichenach | Hugh le Despenser, Earl of Winchester | |
| 1334 | 1335 | Robert de Burton | King Edward 3rd. |
| 1336 | Stephen de Burton | King Edward 3rd. | |
| 1345 | Thomas de Chelreye | King Edward 3rd. | |
| 1364 | 1365 | William Tyrwhit | Prior and Convent of Southwick |
| 1375 | Walter de Brokehampton | Prior and Convent of Southwick | |
| 1375 | Peter Golde | Prior and Convent of Southwick | |
| 1392 | John Newport | Prior and Convent of Southwick | |
| 1392 | John Bernard | Prior and Convent of Southwick | |
| Peter Gynen (Res 1399) | |||
| 1399 | Adam Barnabe | Prior and Convent of Southwick | |
| 1406 | 1407 | Robert Monkestone | Prior and Convent of Southwick |
| ? | |||
| John Quarley | Prior and Convent of Southwick | ||
| 1463 | 1464 | Nicholas Humbryston | Prior and Convent of Southwick |
| John Olney | Prior and Convent of Southwick | ||
| James Whitsong (Res.1493) | Prior and Convent of Southwick | ||
| 1493 | William Cutstone | Prior and Convent of Southwick | |
| 1497 | William Semar | Prior and Convent of Southwick | |
| Walter Martin | |||
| 1525 | Thomas Watson | Prior and Convent of Southwick | |
| 1556 | 1557 | William Irish | James Mussoche |
| 1558 | John Somers | William pound | |
| 1578 | John Winter | Ellen Pound | |
| 1600 | 1601 | Edward Beareblock | Thomas Henslow |
| 1619 | Jethro Beale | William Fowle | |
| Robert Lester (Intruder) | |||
| 1662 | Francis Nelson | Richard Goldstone | |
| 1689 | Edmund Cornwall | Thomas Brereton | |
| 1726 | William Chicheley | Sir John Chicheley | |
| 1737 | Peter Evans | Thomas Smith | |
| 1781 | Roger Cole | C W Taylor | |
| 1789 | John Burrough | C W Taylor | |
| 1803 | Griffith Richards | C W Taylor | |
| 1826 | Edward Tew Richards | Daniel Davies | |
| 1887 | Arthur James Richards | ||
| 1925 | Feb. 1934 | Robert Leatherdale Leatherdale | Rev. A J Richards |
| 1934 | Basil Camden Daniell | Exors. Of Rev A J Richards | |
| 1938 | Cecil Booth | Exors. Of Rev A J Richards | |
| 1965 | 1975 | Alfred Oswald Sills | Miss Richards and Mrs Brooks |
| 1975 | 1989 | John Rowan Pilkington | Dr Leatherdale and Mrs Brooks |
| 1989 | 2002 | John Ridout Pinder | Dr Leatherdale and Mrs Brooks |
| 2002 | 2009 | Stephen Bruce Summers | Edward George Nugee and Sarah Jetton Wynter Bee |
| 2010 | Paul David Gully | Edward George Nugee and Sarah Jetton Wynter Bee |